What if it all works out? Noticing the Inner Critic in Coaching

Most of my coaching sessions have three people in them. My client, me, and an uninvited guest who never stops talking.
You probably know this guest. It’s the inner critic. It cuts in with “But what if this goes wrong?” and “What if they want me to fail?” It replays last Tuesday’s meeting on a loop. It reminds my brilliant, hardworking, deeply kind clients of every reason they might not be worthy.
I can’t coach an inner critic. It’s one of the first things you learn in coaching training. So, I reach for every tool in my kit to help us bypass it and get to the real conversation underneath.
Then recently, I had a session where I noticed the uninvited guest barely showed up. It’s not like this client has had it easy. They are navigating a culture I would generously call “challenging.” Yet they are soaring.
After the session, I realized what was different. Their inner chatter is quiet. In its place is a voice that sounds like a best friend and a seasoned mentor rolled into one, living right in their gut. When they talk about a recent win, that voice lets them actually enjoy it. When they talk about a misstep, the same voice says, essentially, “Okay, that stung. What did we learn and what’s next?” Compassionate, yes. But also the kind of kick in the butt that feels like someone cheering you on rather than piling on the guilt.
Let me be clear. Kindness is not a substitute for courage and grit. This client has both in spades. What the kinder voice gives them is access. Access to celebrating their wins, trusting their judgment and bouncing back from their blunders. Feedback lands as information instead of a verdict on who they are. That nagging, shouting voice doesn’t get to hijack their thinking or steal their joy.
I’m not a psychologist. I’m more of a “professional noticer.” What I notice is that some people have learned to turn down the volume on their critic, and some were lucky enough to be born with a gentler one. Either way, it is such an unlock.
So here’s what I’m sitting with, and I invite you to sit with it too:
What if you swapped “What if everything goes wrong?” for “What if it all works out?”
Would that make you naive? Or would it open up more space, more creativity and more joy in the beautifully messy business of living?
I’m betting on the latter.
📚 If you want to go deeper on your inner voice, I’m reading Chatter by psychologist Ethan Kross right now and highly recommend it.




Comments